Your horizontal imagery is also well done. That can be a real challenge (one site I worked on abandoned it because of the difficulty of the 900×200 obstacle. I suppose it helps to have a professional photographer on staff! One thing about those graphic headers was they seemed inconsistent to me. I could never anticipate when it would be horizontal art and when it was going to be a right-side vertical image. I don’t suppose it matters to most people, but if it was supposed to indicated hierarchy, I couldn’t (or didn’t take the time to) figure it out.

Since Media pages are so popular these days (good choice to have it as a primary nav option), I spent some time looking around there. It’s great that you post audio and video from so many services (I didn’t even know that ResLife offered a Sunday evening service!). However, if I want to listen/download the audio from a series, I have to spend a lot of time hunting through the list. I have two thoughts: 1) offer a search/sort option based on series name and/or 2) include a thumbnail of the key art for that series to help people sort visually.

I know Websites can seem like a forever process. Good job pushing through to launch on this one!

You might like to try putting it through Internet Evangelism Day’s church site self-assessment tool:
InternetEvangelismDay.com/design

Blessings

Tony